Camille Faivre is a seasoned authority in higher education management, widely recognized for her strategic oversight of institutional transitions in the post-pandemic era. As law schools navigate the dual pressures of maintaining academic rigor while managing the fiscal realities of 2026, Faivre has become a pivotal voice in the debate over accreditation standards. With the American Bar Association’s accreditation arm recently moving to eliminate the long-standing requirement for full-time faculty in foundational first-year courses, she offers a unique perspective on how these changes balance institutional flexibility with the student experience. This conversation explores the intersection of federal regulatory oversight, the shifting role of adjunct instructors, and the evolving financial model of legal education.
How do you anticipate the shift away from full-time faculty mandates for first-year courses will reshape the financial landscape and the accessibility of legal education for incoming students?
The financial implications are primarily driven by the palpable pressure from the Justice Department, which has signaled that these rigid staffing requirements could trigger an antitrust investigation. Associate Attorney General Stanley Woodward has been very vocal, suggesting that by limiting the role of adjunct faculty, schools are essentially driving up costs and creating an artificial barrier that hurts students. From a management perspective, shifting toward adjuncts is a clear cost-saving measure because these professionals are significantly less expensive to hire than tenured or tenure-track professors. When schools are no longer forced to have full-time faculty teach “substantially all” of their first-year curriculum, they gain the fiscal breathing room to potentially lower tuition or at least slow its growth. This move toward flexibility is a direct response to warnings that the previous standard was an undue burden on the 200 law schools currently under the council’s oversight.
What are the primary concerns regarding the student experience and the pedagogical foundation of a legal career if schools move away from a full-time faculty model during that critical first year?
There is a deep concern among faculty leadership, particularly at institutions like the University of Colorado Boulder, that we are risking the very “community” that defines the 1L experience. The first year is a rigorous, almost sensory immersion into core legal principles and analytical methods; it is where the “legal mind” is forged through constant feedback and sequencing of complex learning. Full-time professors are viewed as essential here because they are physically and mentally more available to answer student questions outside of the classroom, making it a central part of their professional identity. If we move toward a model where instructors are rushing from their law firms to the classroom, we might lose that pedagogical expertise that comes from a full-time commitment to course design. The fear is that the community will feel more transactional, losing the richness of a dedicated academic environment where faculty are always present to mentor students through the most difficult year of their lives.
In what ways could the increased involvement of sitting judges and emeritus professors as adjuncts actually improve the practical readiness of law graduates?
The argument for this change, championed by leaders like Terence Lau at Syracuse University, is that it allows law schools to tap into a wealth of “firsthand experience” that full-time academics might lack. Imagine a first-year student learning the basics of civil procedure not just from a textbook, but from a sitting judge who sees these rules applied every single morning in a real courtroom. This provides a sensory, practical bridge between theory and practice that can be incredibly inspiring for a student who is struggling with abstract doctrines. Schools want the ability to draw on these high-level practitioners and emeritus professors where they best serve the students’ need for real-world context. By removing the “undue burden” of the full-time requirement, institutions can curate a more diverse teaching staff that reflects the current legal market rather than just the ivory tower.
With the Department of Education recently recommending the removal of federal recognition for the accreditation council, what does this mean for the future of financial aid and institutional stability?
The situation is incredibly tense right now because losing federal recognition would mean the council could no longer act as the gatekeeper for Title IV financial aid. While only five of the 200 law schools currently rely on the council for this specific access, the symbolic and regulatory fallout would be massive for the entire network. A report from federal staffers recently alleged that the council was non-compliant with over two dozen federal criteria, raising serious questions about its independence from the ABA’s professional organization. We are currently waiting for Education Under Secretary Nicholas Kent to make a final call on this matter after a federal advisory panel deadlocked on the vote. It feels like a regulatory storm is brewing, and schools are having to prepare for a future where their primary accreditor might lose the very authority that gives their degrees federal weight.
What is your forecast for the evolution of accreditation standards over the next few years?
I expect we will see a continuing trend toward extreme institutional flexibility, forced by both federal oversight and the need for competitive pricing in a crowded market. The council has already moved to repeal diversity standards recently, following a suspension in early 2025, which shows they are willing to backtrack quickly under political or legal pressure. Over the next few years, from 2026 to 2028, I predict we will see more law schools adopting “hybrid” faculty models where the core identity of the school is maintained by a smaller group of full-time “pedagogical experts,” while the bulk of specialized and foundational instruction is handled by elite practitioners. This will likely lead to a bifurcation in the market: elite schools will double down on the full-time faculty “community” as a luxury brand, while others will embrace the adjunct-heavy model to keep the lights on and keep tuition manageable. The final decision by the House of Delegates in February will be the first major indicator of whether this shift is permanent or just a temporary concession to the Justice Department.
